Who survives the holocaust??

Vote

Want to post a match question to the forums?

It's easy! Simply click the "open for debate" link on any match question.

HeartMachine

Dec 10, 2008

Well Punks just like to fight and drink beer and be who they want to be. So I have to say Punks obviously win.
danroche01

Dec 10, 2008

Old punks are some of the most macho people you'll ever meet. The first show I ever went to (besides when my sister brought me to see GG Allin recite spoken word when I was maybe ten or eleven, you can find it on the youtube, search "an evening with GG Allin") was the UK Subs in '93. It was like a war, I don't think I've seen a pit that violent since. But I also saw crazy, bone-cracking pits at DOA, MDC, Los Crudos, and Warzone. And the Slapshot reunion shows. There are a few I'm forgetting, but those are the ones that immediately stand out as the most life, health, and sanity threatening shows I remember. If you're including tough guy hardcore, I don't see how the goths stand a chance.
xGnomex

Dec 10, 2008

I did read where the goth sub culture was influenced by early punk... thus industrial was born. So the two do have some connection.
Can't we all just get along?
danroche01

Dec 10, 2008

Joy Division was originally a punk band named Warsaw. Alternatively, the UK rave subculture was pretty heavily influenced by the DIY anarcho-punk, certainly politically if not musically.
HeartMachine

Dec 10, 2008

I thought the some members of Joy Division were also in New Order originally correct me if I'm wrong. And you're right about originally hardcore when it comes to bands like Madballs and Agnostic Front.
danroche01

Dec 10, 2008

New Order is Joy Division sans Ian Curtis after Ian took a dirt nap. Warsaw --> Joy Division --> New Order
BuzzBuzzard

Dec 10, 2008

Punks.
-Luci-

Dec 10, 2008

Well, I think punks because of sheer numbers and blatent impulsiveness and violence, but the goths would be more likely to plan an attack. They could come from behind and give the punks a run for their money before they're completely flattened by one of The Wo's many guitars
f3ralanarchy

Dec 10, 2008

punks
Compute

Dec 10, 2008

The punks, of course. Christ, it's not even a contest. That's like asking who would win in a battle between a wood chipper and a basket full of kittens.
CoffeeColleen

Dec 10, 2008

Goths aren't scared shitless of death... they love death. Therefore the punks would win. Especially since most of the punks I've known have been lil on the violent side.... lol! So yeah, definitely no contest.
f3ralanarchy

Dec 10, 2008

colleen can i be your punk? just point to them and i'll make them disappear :O)
Hibiscusilicous

Dec 11, 2008

Goths do have a fighting chance though. Punks might get too drunk and high and pass out, leaving them vulnerable to....uh.... drug overdose?
chinesepride

Dec 11, 2008

who would win 2 punks like normal street thugs one with chain and another 1 with baseball bat vs iron mike tyson (no weapons)
Casanuda

Dec 11, 2008

Yeah I've never heard of a punk that can handle an eight ball or two... Punks are conditioned for violence as long as they can avoid beating themselves to death they should do quite well.
danroche01

Dec 11, 2008

^^ that sounds like a really fucking good 1988 Nintendo game
SillyCreole

Dec 11, 2008

Punks 1st round easy win.
Kat-o-nine

Dec 11, 2008

depends entirely upon the individual i think, this little goth girl could beat just about anybody's arse. And for the record, i am neither terrified of death, nor obsessed with it.
FatherZossima

Dec 11, 2008

I had a goth cry at me once. It was terrifying.
MorgaaBDemented

Dec 11, 2008

I don't know who would win, but I'll volunteer my vagina for the location of the battle.

Post a comment