Message Him

Join OkCupid

Find better matches with our advanced matching system

—% Match —% Friend —% Enemy

akdjfaodsif

39 / M / Bisexual / Single

Seattle, Washington

His journal posts

Remakes and Reboots...

Aug 29, 2012

So often new movies come out and everyone complains about the "new" movie being a remake, reboot, copy, rip-off, and the like of an older movie.  Then starts the discussion that Hollywood has no new ideas, that all they can do is recycle older movies.  I get that, I'm one of the people that's constantly complaining about things like that. However, what I would like to propose is that remakes and reboots aren't always a bad thing. Yes, sometimes they suck terribly; but sometimes the new movie is worth being made.

Here are some movies that I really enjoyed - maybe not as much as the original, but they are still good movies that are worth watching.

Scarface (1983 - Pacino)  from Scarface (1932 - about Al Capone). An amazing modern (at the time of release) retelling/adaptation of the original. 

The Thing (1982 - Kurt Russel, John Carpenter) from The Thing from Another World (1951).  Both based on a book.  The Thing '82 is an amazing movie about paranoia, and for the time has amazing special effects for the time.

A Fistful of Dollars (1964 - Clint Eastwood) & Last Man Standing (1996 - Bruce Willis) from Yojimbo (1961 - Akira Kurosawa).  All three amazing movies. If you haven't seen the original by Kurosawa I strongly recommend it.  He was very influential and even George Lucas used several of his techniques in Star Wars (which has elements of Kurosawa's The Hidden Fortress)

Those are my three favorites, but there's also The Fly ('86), Dawn of the Dead ('04), Let Me In ('10),  The Magnificent 7 (another Kurosawa remake), The Departed, Casino Royale, True Grit.

The point is, not every remake is horrible.  Sometimes the remake, reboot, re-imagining, etc will have a new or novel approach to a classic that makes it interesting in it's own right. Sometimes it's just well put together with acting, pacing, and special effects.   And yes, I realize that most remakes are probably crap, and the good ones are the exception - but that really isn't different than "original" movies.

So often new movies come out and everyone complains about the"new" movie being a remake, reboot, copy, rip-off, and the like ofan older movie.  Then starts the discussion that Hollywood hasno new ideas, that all they can do is recycle older movies.  Iget that, I'm one of the people that's constantly complaining aboutthings like that. However, what I would like to propose is thatremakes and reboots aren't always a bad thing. Yes,sometimes they suck terribly; but sometimes the new movie is worthbeing made.

Here are some movies that I really enjoyed - maybe not as muchas the original, but they are still good movies that are worthwatching.

Scarface (1983 - Pacino)  from Scarface(1932 - about Al Capone). An amazing modern (at the time ofrelease) retelling/adaptation of the original. 

The Thing (1982 - Kurt Russel, John Carpenter)from The Thing from Another World (1951).  Both based on abook.  The Thing '82 is an amazing movie about paranoia, andfor the time has amazing special effects for the time.

A Fistful of Dollars (1964 - Clint Eastwood)& Last Man Standing (1996 - Bruce Willis) from Yojimbo (1961 -Akira Kurosawa).  All three amazing movies. If you haven'tseen the original by Kurosawa I strongly recommend it.  He wasvery influential and even George Lucas used several of histechniques in Star Wars (which has elements of Kurosawa's TheHidden Fortress)

Those are my three favorites, but there's also The Fly ('86),Dawn of the Dead ('04), Let Me In ('10),  The Magnificent 7(another Kurosawa remake), The Departed, Casino Royale, TrueGrit.

The point is, not every remake is horrible.  Sometimes theremake, reboot, re-imagining, etc will have a new or novel approachto a classic that makes it interesting in it's own right. Sometimesit's just well put together with acting, pacing, and specialeffects.   And yes, I realize that most remakes areprobably crap, and the good ones are the exception - but thatreally isn't different than "original" movies.

Remakes and Reboots...
An image of SixOfSpades The thing to remember is that remakes must be *justified*, they need more of a reason to exist than original films. Perhaps they're justified because that, when the original was made X years ago, they just didn't have the technology to make the imagery work, and now they do (case in point: King Kong). Perhaps they're justified in that by changing major elements of the story, while still keeping the critical plot points, they can help us focus on the essential elements and themes (such as King Lear turning into Ran). Perhaps they're justified in that previous versions were really badly done, and the story itself needs an apology (e.g., the Batman franchise). The fact that the film would (probably) make money is not justification, yet that "reason" is used so often I won't even bother to cite examples. Also non-viable is the creation of a remake in order to reach a different target audience (Death at a Funeral), or merely to "update" the film with more modern technology that doesn't really change the plot (War of the Worlds).

SixOfSpades commented on Aug 29, 2012

An image of __whatever Fistful of Dollars was awesome. Also Scarface, Dawn of the Dead, and The Fly (with Goldblum). I didn't see a lot of the others. The Thing was boring to me when I saw it and I keep meaning to watch it as an adult but never do. I did love Let the Right One In but never got around to the English version.

__whatever commented on Aug 30, 2012

An image of akdjfaodsif The first 20 or so minutes of The Thing w/ Kurt Russell was all about mood and atmosphere. Then things start to get really weird. I think it's well worth watching again. As for the new War of the Worlds, I didn't think it was a bad adaptation and don't mind it as a remake any more than King Kong. There were things they couldn't do in the original - like the Tripods, so they turned them into flying saucers. It's the movie industry - it's like any other industry. It's about making money. I don't mind that so long as the product is good, ie. worth buying.

akdjfaodsif commented on Aug 30, 2012