• Hi! And welcome to my Captain America vs. Batman Test. The age old question of comic nerds everywhere can finally be put to an objective test. Who would win in a fight between Captain America and Batman? There are a few ways to take the test. Pick the answer that matches you best which will give you an idea of which iconic super hero you're most like; Pick the answer that best describes the "winner" of the question which will give you an idea of who should win in a fight; or just pick the answer which most likely coincides with your own opinions on the matter.